Social and Environmental Influences on Mate Attraction, Mate Choice and Territorial Defence

Males often possess traits, such as horns, claws and tusks, which are used during male-male combat. Studies suggest that selection has fine-tuned these weapons to improve their effectiveness and that the shape of these weapons provide cues for males to assess the strength of rivals. Similarly, females might also assess a male’s weaponry to determine his value as a mate. The largest weapon relative to body size is the major claw of male fiddler crabs (Genus: Uca). Males use their claws both as a weapon and as a courtship signal, waving it to attract females. We used robotic crabs in two-choice experiments to test female mating preferences based on male claw shape in U. mjoebergi. First, females did not prefer conspecific claws over any of three alternatively shaped stimuli matched for color and for the rate and pattern of waving. The alternative stimuli were two different heterospecific claws and a plain rectangular shape. Second, females significantly preferred the alternative stimuli when they were presented at a faster wave rate. We conclude that claw shape in U. mjoebergi has not evolved under sexual selection imposed by female mating preferences, and is more likely to have evolved under selection for effectiveness during male-male competition.